My Journey to a CURE
  • Welcome
  • Special Thanks
  • Blog
  • My Favorite Products
  • Contact Email
  • Free Motivational & Inspirational E-Books
  • Magic of Magnesium
  • Johns Journey to a Prostate Cure
  • BioReigns Science and Testing
  • BioReigns About Us
  • CBD Published Studies All Health Conditions
  • CS BrainSense
  • Smart UV Products
  • CS Muscadine
  • CS Muscadine Seed Oil

Aetna Owes $26M Over Denied Cancer Treatment, Jury Says

11/9/2018

 
This is GREAT NEWS for all of those Patients who are denied coverage for Proton Therapy even though they have this treatment in their policies.   (Johns doctor had to go back and forth with our insurance carrier and prove that Proton Therapy had to be done as it was better for him than radiation or surgery.)  In the end they agreed with our doctor and allowed the treatment.  This should not be an issue IF a doctor says it is necessary for any patient IF it is covered in their policy.  I always wondered how an insurance company can decide which is best for you.   

​Some important facts to review if you are denied coverage ~ 
Top 10 Myths about Proton Therapy for Prostate Cancer. ​
Picture
You may be surprised to learn what the insurance carriers don't seem to know especially when they tell your doctor it is experimental.   

Here are the top 3:

Proton therapy was FDA approved for use in the U.S. in 1988—24 years ago

Berkeley Radiation Laboratory treated the first patient with protons in 1954.

Medicare and about 180 private insurers consider proton therapy an established technology, and have been reimbursing for proton therapy for more than 20 years.


​​Aetna Owes $26M Over Denied Cancer Treatment, Jury Says
Law360 (November 8, 2018, 6:33 PM EST)

An Oklahoma jury this week slammed Aetna with two verdicts totaling nearly $25.6 million, finding the insurer willfully acted in bad faith when it repeatedly refused to cover proton beam therapy recommended for a woman’s cancer.   The Oklahoma City jury returned on Monday with a liability and compensatory damages verdict in favor of plaintiffs Ron Cunningham and the estate of his deceased wife, Orrana Cunningham, and on Tuesday found in their favor after a second-phase trial on punitive damages, according to the case docket.

The plaintiffs had alleged that Aetna Life Insurance Company had acted in bad faith in refusing to cover proton beam therapy — a type of targeted radiation treatment — recommended by the doctors treating Orrana Cunningham’s nasopharynx squamous carcinoma, a cancer located in the upper part of the throat near the base of the skull.

After deliberating for roughly three hours following a 12-day trial, the jury on Monday awarded $15 million to Orrana Cunningham’s estate and $500,000 to Ron Cunningham for emotional distress, and roughly $92,000 for their out-of-pocket spending on the cancer treatment, according to Cunningham attorney Doug Terry of Doug Terry Law. On Tuesday the jury awarded $10 million in punitive damages, according to Terry. The verdict forms were not available on the case docket as of Thursday.

“The people of Oklahoma county spoke loudly to send a message to the insurance industry that they’re not going to put up with insurance companies that recklessly disregard the rights of their policyholders, and we hope the verdict will help other people dealing with that in the future,” Terry told Law360 on Thursday.

Aetna had rejected coverage of the proton therapy — recommended because Orrana Cunningham’s cancer was so close to her brain — because the therapy was purportedly experimental, but that the evidence showed that the Aetna doctors who made those decisions spent less than an hour evaluating the case, Terry said.

“They were unqualified medically to be making these decisions, they were untrained in how to properly investigate and evaluate an insurance claim, they were overworked because they were handling way too many claims,” he said.

In a company statement, Aetna said its sympathies were with the Cunninghams, but that the public court record showed it had followed the proper procedures in the case. Aetna covered “proven safe and effective” radiation therapy, but the Cunninghams chose to instead pursue the proton beam therapy, for which there is a lack of clinical data, according to the statement.

Aetna’s denial was upheld through two levels of internal appeal, as well a review by an independent radiation oncologist — a review that was not permitted to be used at trial, according to the statement.

Aetna’s statement said it had no comment on “juror motives” or a potential appeal, but wanted to be clear that it followed the proper steps in denying the coverage.

The Cunninghams filed their suit on May 18, 2015, alleging that Aetna owed coverage under Ron Cunningham’s policy, which he obtained as an Oklahoma City firefighter. Orrana Cunningham was receiving treatment at Houston’s M.D. Anderson Cancer Center, and the doctors there recommended the proton beam treatment, according to their complaint.

Ron Cunningham mortgaged the farmhouse he had built with his wife in Meeker, Oklahoma, to obtain the roughly $90,000 he needed to pay out-of-pocket for the proton beam therapy, and after receiving the treatment his wife was improving and was released from the hospital, according to Terry.

On May 30, 2015, Orrana Cunningham died at age 54 of a viral infection that entered her brain and caused her brain stem to rupture, according to Terry.

The plaintiffs are represented by Doug Terry of Doug Terry Law and Justin D. Meek and Tom Paruolo of DeWitt Paruolo Meek.

Aetna is represented by John B. Shely and Laura Trenaman of Hunton Andrews Kurth LLP, Leasa M. Stewart of GableGotwals and Frederick P. Santarelli, Stewart J. Greenleaf Jr. and Sherine N. Bedlako of Elliott Greenleaf PC.

The case is Ron Cunningham et al. v. Aetna Life Insurance Company, case number CJ-2015-2826 in the District Court of Oklahoma County, State of Oklahoma.

Thank you to Law360
--Editing by Alanna Weissman.
Share us on:    By Daniel Siegal
https://www.law360.com/trials/articles/1100324/aetna-owes-26m-over-denied-cancer-treatment-jury-says


​

Comments are closed.

    Categories

    All
    Adaptogen
    Air Purification
    Alkalinize PH
    Allergy
    Aloe Vera
    Alzheimers
    Amazon
    Amish Origins Pain Relief Cream
    Anti Aging
    Antioxidant
    Anxiety
    Apple Cider Vinegar
    Arginine
    Arthritis
    Artificial Sweeteners
    Aspartame
    Asthma
    Auto Immune
    B-12
    Back Pain
    Bacteria
    Baking Soda
    Beet Root Super Powder
    Beta Glucan
    BioDefense
    BioReign
    Bioreigns Cbd
    Birth Defects
    Black Cumin
    Black Seed Oil
    Books
    Brain Function
    Brain Mental Vitality
    Brain Sense
    Breast Cancer
    Broccoli
    Burns
    Calcium
    Cancer
    Cancer Awareness Jewelry
    Cancer Treatments
    Cardiovascular
    Carrot Powder Organic
    Cayenne Pepper
    CBD Hemp Organic
    CBD - Hemp - Organic
    Cell Fuzion
    Cell Phone
    Cell Phone Radiation
    Chlorine Shower
    Chloroquine
    Cholestrol
    Cleaning
    Cleaning Fruits & Produce
    Cleanses
    Cleansing
    Collagen
    Colon
    Colonel Joe
    Corey's Digs
    Coronavirus
    Corpus Christi Water Contamination
    Cortisol
    Covid 19 Virus
    CS BrainSense
    Curcumin
    Cyanobacteria
    D3 And K2
    Dandelion Root
    Dementia
    Depression
    Detox
    DIABETES
    Diet
    Digestion
    Digestive
    Disease Prevention
    Disinfectant
    Dna Repair
    Dog Monitor Camera
    DOGS
    Elderberry
    EMF Protection
    EMR Defender
    Energy
    Environment Friendly
    Enzymes
    Essential Oils
    Extra Virgin Olive Oil
    Fatigue
    Fatty Liver
    FDA
    Fish Oil
    Florida Eco Disaster
    Flu
    Fluoride
    Free E Books
    Free Mart Products
    Germs
    Global Healing
    Glyphosate
    Grape-seed-extract
    Greens
    Green Tea
    Green-tea
    Groupon
    Gut Health
    Hair And Nails
    Hair Loss Growth
    Hand Sanitizer DIY\
    Hand Wipes - DIY
    Hart Procedure
    Headaches
    Healthy Hair And Nails
    Healthy Joints
    Healthy Skin
    Heart Disease
    Herbicides
    High Blood Pressure
    Holidays
    Huperzine-hupa
    Hydrate
    Hydroxychloroquine
    Hypertension
    Immune Support
    Immune System
    Immune-system
    Immunotherapy
    Inflammation
    Inspiration
    Iodine
    Johns Journey
    Joint Pain
    Kidney Disease
    Lemons
    Limitless
    Liver
    Liver Cleanse
    L Serine
    Lung
    Lycopene
    Magnesium
    Meal Replacement
    Memory
    Minerals
    MiracleII
    Monsanto
    Moringa
    Muscadine
    Muscadine Grape
    Muscadine Seed Oil
    Mushrooms
    My Story
    Nano Soma
    Natural Fertilizer
    Nervous System
    Nigella Sativa
    Now We No Movement
    Nutrition
    Off The Grid
    Olive Leaf Extract
    Omega 3
    On The Go Knowledge Pantry
    Oregano
    Organic Health
    Organic Herbal Extracts
    Organic Teas
    ORGANOPHOSPHATE
    Osteoarthritis
    Oxygen
    Pain Relief
    Pancreatic Cancer
    Parkinsons
    Pesticides
    Pet Health
    Pets
    Poisoning
    Pollen
    Pomegranate
    Prebiotics
    Precious Prills
    Preparation
    Probiotic
    Prostate Cancer
    Protein
    Quercetin
    Radiation
    Rashes
    Raspex
    Red Tide Illness
    Red Tide Illness Remedies
    Red Tide TOXIC BACTERIA
    Remdesivir
    Respiratory
    Restore
    Resveratrol
    Reverse Osmosis
    Sage
    Sale
    Sanitary Napkins
    Saving Money (Earning $)
    Selenium
    Sept 11
    Shark Cartilage
    Shiaqga
    Shopping
    Siahus
    Siesta Key Red Tide TOXIC Algae
    Silver
    Sinus
    Sleep
    Slver
    Soap Ans Laundry
    Special
    Special Thanks
    Sponsors Movies Websites
    Stem Cell
    Stress
    Sunburn
    Sunscreen
    Superfoods
    Supplement Discounts
    TAKE ACTION
    Testimonial
    Thyroid
    Thyroid Health
    Toothpaste
    Toxic Metals
    Toxin Removal
    Toxins
    Turmeric
    Veterans
    Vitamin B12
    Vitamin C
    Vitamin D3
    Vitamin K2
    Washing Your Hands
    Water
    Water Devices Treatments
    Water Filtration
    Weed Control
    Weight Loss
    Welcome
    Wrinkle Removal
    Wrinkles
    Zeolite DHQ
    Zeotrex
    Zinc
    ZNatural

    Archives

    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    July 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    May 2019
    March 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    February 2015
    July 2014
    June 2014
    November 2011

    RSS Feed

    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Zeotrex® is an herbal blend that helps rejuvenate vitality, energy, mental clarity, and overall wellness through the detoxification of chemicals and metals.
    Picture
    Pura Vida Best Sellers
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Click to set custom HTML

    Picture

    Fluoride Filter
    11 Free Tips to Reduce Your Fluoride Exposure
    Picture
    Picture
    Save up to 33% with Bundle Deals -  Shop Now
    Phenoh
My Journey to A Cure Copyright 2010 - 2022